Comparison of Sugar ‘n Cream Yarn with Other Cotton Yarns

Brand
Fiber Content
Yardage (yards)
Price per Skein (USD)
Available Colors
Customer Reviews
Lily Sugar ‘n Cream 100% Cotton 120 2.99 39 Durable, great for dishcloths, machine washable, absorbs well.
Hobbii Rainbow Cotton 100% Cotton 82 2.75 64 Soft and great for amigurumi, but can be a bit splitty; overall positive reception.
Crafter’s Secret Cotton 100% Cotton 235 3.99 40 Soft, durable, ideal for multiple projects, slightly thinner feel compared to some other brands.
Peaches & Creme 100% Cotton 160 2.5 36 Durable, versatile, ideal for projects like washcloths. Quality rated highly with some concerns about ease of use.
Bernat Handicrafter 95% Cotton 5% Other (Recycled Fibers) 84 1.99 49 Ultra-soft, absorbent, and durable. Ideal for home accessories but may split easily when worked with.
Rico Creative Cotton 100% Cotton 115 7.95 n/a Soft and pliable with a light hand, delivers delightful results; well-regarded by users.
Scheepjes Cotton 100% Cotton 186 4.99 n/a Soft, versatile, suitable for various crafts.
Katia Fair Cotton 100% Organic Cotton 170 4.8 n/a Ideal for sensitive skin, soft feel, suitable for baby garments, and basic garments alike.
King Cole Giza Cotton 100% Mercerized Cotton 272 5 28 Soft, lustrous, great for garments and home projects, highly rated for quality.

Based on the search results and the provided table, here’s how Lily Sugar ‘n Cream yarn compares to other cotton yarns:

1. Price and Value:
– Sugar ‘n Cream is priced at $2.99 for 120 yards, which works out to about $0.025 per yard.
– It’s one of the more affordable options compared to some other brands.
– Peaches & Creme offers slightly better value at $2.50 for 160 yards ($0.016 per yard).

2. Fiber Content and Quality:
– Sugar ‘n Cream is 100% cotton, like many other popular brands.
– It’s known for being durable and machine washable.
– The yarn is made from USA-grown cotton.

3. Versatility:
– It’s widely used for household items like dishcloths, washcloths, and other kitchen/bath accessories.
– While suitable for these purposes, some softer cotton yarns might be preferred for wearables.

4. Color Range:
– Sugar ‘n Cream offers 39 solid colors, which is a good range.
– Some brands like Scheepjes Catona (105 colors) and Yarn and Colours Must Have (100 colors) offer more extensive color options.

5. Texture and Feel:
– It’s described as having a “soft or rough cotton-y feel.”
– Some users find it slightly stiffer compared to more premium cotton yarns, especially before washing.

6. Popularity and Availability:
– It’s one of the most popular and widely available cotton yarns, especially in North America.
– You can find it in many craft stores and online retailers.

7. Alternatives:
– Crafter’s Secret Cotton Yarn (from Hobby Lobby) is noted as an almost exact match, slightly cheaper at $2.29 for 120 yards.
– For those seeking softer options, brands like Bendigo Woollen Mills 8 ply, Cascade Ultra Pima, or King Cole Cotton Soft are mentioned as softer alternatives.

In summary, Lily Sugar ‘n Cream is a popular, affordable, and versatile 100% cotton yarn that’s particularly well-suited for household items. While there are softer and more luxurious cotton yarns available, Sugar ‘n Cream offers good value for its intended uses and is a go-to choice for many crafters, especially for kitchen and bath projects.

Citations:
[1] https://marlybird.com/blog/the-best-cotton-yarn-in-every-yarn-weight/
[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/knitting/comments/106edt6/recommendations_for_a_high_quality_soft_cotton/
[3] https://littleworldofwhimsy.com/my-honest-review-of-lily-sugarn-cream-yarn-by-yarnspirations/
[4] https://www.woolbox.co.uk/collections/cotton-yarns.html
[5] https://shelleyhusbandcrochet.com/cotton-yarn-test-review-part-5-winner/
[6] https://hyggecrochetco.com/best-cotton-yarn-for-crochet/
[7] https://www.caabcrochet.com/best-cotton-yarns/
[8] https://creativecraftingworld.co.uk/product/lily-sugarn-cream-yarn-71g/
[9] https://littleworldofwhimsy.com/my-honest-review-of-lily-sugarn-cream-yarn-by-yarnspirations/
[10] https://hobbii.com/rainbow-cotton-8-8
[11] https://amenagerieofstitchesblog.com/hobbii-yarn-review/
[12] https://raffamusadesigns.com/hobbii-rainbow-cotton-yarn-review/
[13] https://yarnsub.com/yarns/hobby_lobby/crafters_secret_cotton
[14] http://missabigailshopechest.blogspot.com/2016/01/review-crafters-secret-yarn.html
[15] https://crochetistheway.blogspot.com/2015/06/yarn-review-peaches-creme.html
[16] https://yarnsub.com/yarns/bernat/handicrafter_cotton_solids
[17] https://www.marymaxim.com/products/bernat-handicrafter-cotton-yarn
[18] https://sweetbeecrochet.com/bernat-handicrafter-review/
[19] https://www.rico-design.de/en/collections/hand-knitting/yarn-collection-hand-knitting/
[20] https://www.laughinghens.com/knitting-wool/rico-creative-cotton-aran
[21] https://www.scheepjes.com/en/cotton-8-330/
[22] https://www.katia.com/modelo.php/yarns-spring-summer-faircotton-1018.html
[23] https://www.sabines-handarbeitsshop.de/Yarns-Wool/material/Cotton/Katia-FAIR-COTTON.htm?ProdNr=KA1018&a=article&p=68&shop=sh_en
[24] https://magicscissors.com/katia-yarns/katia-fair-cotton-infinity-13391.html
[25] https://shopyarnia.com/giza-cotton-dk-updating/

Scroll to Top